Showing posts with label Midwest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Midwest. Show all posts

Sunday, January 16, 2022

CAFOs and Surface Water Quality: Evidence from Wisconsin

Abstract:
Concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs)—animal feeding operations with over 1,000 animal units in confined spaces—have proliferated over the past thirty years in the United States. CAFOs provide operational cost savings, but higher animal concentrations in confined spaces can generate external costs, for example, non-point source water pollution. In this study,  Zach Raff  and Andrew Meyer improve on previous research designs to estimate the relationship between the growth in CAFOs and surface water quality using longitudinal data on a large spatial scale.  Raff and Meyer use a panel dataset from 1995–2017 that links CAFO intensity with nearby surface water quality readings in Wisconsin to perform our analysis. Leveraging variation in CAFO intensity within hydrological regions over time, they find that increasing CAFO intensity increases the levels of nutrients, specifically total phosphorus and ammonia, in surface water; adding one CAFO to a Hydrologic Unit Code-8 (HUC8) region leads to a 1.7% increase in total phosphorus levels and a 2.7% increase in ammonia levels, relative to sample mean levels. As an important contribution of our work, they use these results to calculate the external costs of surface water quality damages from CAFOs in Wisconsin. Our results imply that the marginal CAFO in Wisconsin produces non-market surface water quality damages of at least $203,541 per year.
...
Raff and Meyer ... use water quality index and benefit transfer methodologies to convert increased nutrient concentrations associated with CAFO expansion to losses in non-market surface water quality benefits, that is, damages. This methodology estimates changes in a water quality index and monetizes the changes with a benefit transfer function. They estimate an annualized WTP (Willingness-To-Pay) of $3–$12 per Wisconsin household for the improved water quality that would exist in the counterfactual world with one fewer CAFO in each HUC8 region. Aggregated to the entire state, Wisconsin households would be willing to pay between $6.9 million and $27.9 million annually for one fewer CAFO in each HUC8 region.
...
Raff and Meyer are aware of only two monetized estimates of CAFO related external costs in dimensions other than surface water quality. First, Herriges, Secchi, and Babcock (2005) estimate that, in Iowa, upwind CAFOs decrease home prices by 3%, which is roughly $2,500 for the average home in their sample. Second, Sneeringer (2010) estimates that the annual air pollution related damages from hogs in the United States are $31 per animal. Applying this value, a CAFO with 2,500 hogs (equivalent to 1,000 animal units) produces $77,500 in air pollution damages per year. In addition to these monetized damages, previous studies find that CAFO exposure is associated with damages to individual health (Sigurdarson and Kline 2005; Radon et al. 2007)50 and occupational safety (Ramos, Fuentes, and Carvajal-Suarez 2018). Other potential, but not yet studied, damages include commercial fishing impacts, increased contamination of private wells, and increased water treatment costs (EPA 2002b).51 To achieve efficiency in CAFO product markets, policymakers and regulatory agencies can use our results, combined with those of previous studies, to develop policy that factors the external costs of CAFOs into their production decisions.

Also important for CAFO policy, they present evidence that the extreme concentration of manure in fewer locations likely drives the surface water quality damages. Thus, CAFO control policy should require better manure management, for example, subsidies to transport the manure off site, to better control the surface water damages from these operations. However, future work should examine the specific avenue by which nutrients enter surface waterbodies, for example, leaching, spreading....
by Zach Raff 1 and Andrew Meyer 2
1. University of Wisconsin-Stout, Menomonie, Wisconsin, USA.
2. Marquette University, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics via Wiley Online American Journal of Agricultural Economics - Wiley Online Library

Sunday, January 3, 2021

Nitrogen Washing Off Midwest Farms Cause Billions in Annual Damage to Gulf of Mexico Fisheries and Marine Habitat, New Study Finds - Dead Zone Compounds Crushing Pandemic Impact on Gulf Fishing Economy

With federal scientists expected to forecast, within days, the size of this year’s “dead zone” in the Gulf of Mexico, a new study shows that one of the dead zone’s biggest causes—nitrogen that flows downriver from Midwest farms—has been responsible for up to $2.4 billion in damages to Gulf fish stocks and their habitat every year for more than 30 years. The amount of nitrogen coming off Midwest corn and soybean farms, according to the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) study, equates to enough fertilizer to fill 3,000 standard size shipping containers every year since 1980 on average.

The economic analysis, detailed in the UCS report “Reviving the Dead Zone: Solutions to Benefit Both Gulf Coast Fishers and Midwest Farmers," built on peer-reviewed research that estimated the damage, in dollars, that a given quantity of excess nitrogen has on fisheries and marine habitat. UCS applied that damage value to the Gulf based upon the peak nitrogen influx between 1980 and 2017.

“Gulf Coast communities know that the dead zone impacts their livelihoods, but research has never put a dollar value on its damage to the fishing industry,” said Rebecca Boehm, an economist at UCS and author of the report. “This study quantifies both the amount of nitrogen flowing to the Gulf from farms upstream, and the toll it is taking economically on the foundation of the Gulf fishing industry.”

For many farmers looking to maximize yields and profits, inexpensive nitrogen fertilizer is a convenient boost to crops. However, increasingly intense rainfall in the spring flushes excess fertilizer into streams and rivers, and much of that nitrogen flows down the Mississippi River into the Gulf of Mexico. Nutrient overload in coastal waters creates low-oxygen areas, which can cause widespread die-offs of some fish and shellfish and drive others from their normal habitat. The persistently large dead zone can lead to reduced catch and increased fuel demands for Gulf fishers who must travel further out for their hauls.















Local residents’ professions, and by extension way of life, seem more threatened now than ever.
“Lots of factors cause shrimpers to lose business, but COVID-19 may completely shut many of us down,” said John Williams, executive director of the Southern Shrimp Alliance and a Gulf shrimper for more than three decades. “Hopefully the industry will get through this health crisis, and in the meantime, we need to address what we can to ensure the Gulf’s long-term sustainability. As long as the dead zone persists, our way of life, and the rich seafood culture of the region is in danger.”





















Monday, January 13, 2020

The Impacts of Harmful Algal Blooms and E. coli on Recreational Behavior in Lake Erie

Abstract:
This paper examines simultaneously the effect of E. coli and harmful algal blooms on recreational behavior using survey data collected from Ohio recreators who visited Lake Erie during the summer of 2016. Using simulation based on latent class models of recreation choice, we find beachgoers and recreational anglers would lose in aggregate $7.7 million and $69.1 million, respectively, each year if water quality conditions were to become so poor that Lake Erie’s western basin were closed. Finally, we recover heterogeneity in recreators’ aversion toward algae and Escherichia coli, with beachgoers more averse to E. coli and anglers more averse to algae.
Eerie Blooms in Lake Erie
https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/145453/eerie-blooms-in-lake-erie
by David Wolf 1, Wei Chen 2, Sathya Gopalakrishnan 3, Timothy Haab 4 and H. Allen Klaiber 5
1. Assistant professor, Department of Economics, University of Wisconsin–Eau Claire; wolfdm@uwec.edu
2. Assistant professor, School of Agricultural Economics and Rural Development, Renmin University of China, Beijing, PR China; chen.4863@osu.edu
3. Associate professor, Department of Agricultural, Environmental, and Development Economics, The Ohio State University, Columbus; gopalakrishnan.27@osu.edu
Professor, Department of Agricultural, Environmental, and Development Economics, The Ohio State University, Columbus; haab.1@osu.edu
5, Professor, Department of Agricultural, Environmental, and Development Economics, The Ohio State University, Columbus; klaiber.16@osu.edu
http://le.uwpress.org/content/95/4/455.abstract
Land Economics http://le.uwpress.org/ via University of Wisconsin Press http://www.uwpress.org/
Volume 95, Number 4; November 1, 2019; pages 455-472

Tuesday, August 28, 2018

Report Confirms Wind Technology Advancements Continue to Drive Down Wind Energy Prices - Key findings indicate wind energy prices at all-time lows as wind turbines grow larger

Wind energy pricing remains attractive, according to an annual report released by the U.S. Department of Energy and prepared by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab). At an average of around 2 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh), prices offered by newly built wind projects in the United States are being driven lower by technology advancements and cost reductions.

“Wind energy prices ­– ­particularly in the central United States, and supported by federal tax incentives – remain at all-time lows, with utilities and corporate buyers selecting wind as a low-cost option,” said Berkeley Lab Senior Scientist Ryan Wiser of the Electricity Markets & Policy Group.

Key findings from the U.S. Department of Energy’s Wind Technologies Market Report include:

Wind power capacity additions continued at a rapid pace in 2017. Nationwide, wind power capacity additions equaled 7,017 megawatts (MW) in 2017, with $11 billion invested in new plants. Wind power constituted 25 percent of all U.S. generation capacity additions in 2017. Wind energy contributed 6.3 percent of the nation’s electricity supply, more than 10 percent of total electricity generation in 14 states, and more than 30 percent in four of those states (Iowa, Kansas, Oklahoma, and South Dakota).

Bigger turbines are enhancing wind project performance. The average generating capacity of newly installed wind turbines in the United States in 2017 was 2.32 MW, up 8 percent from the previous year and 224 percent since 1998-1999. The average rotor diameter in 2017 was 113 meters, a 4 percent increase over the previous year and a 135 percent boost over 1998-1999, while the average hub height in 2017 was 86 meters, up 4 percent from the previous year and 54 percent since 1998-1999. Permit applications to the Federal Aviation Administration suggest that still-taller turbines are on the way. Increased rotor diameters, in particular, have begun to dramatically increase wind project capacity factors. The average 2017 capacity factor among projects built from 2014 through 2016 was 42 percent, compared to an average of 31.5 percent among projects built from 2004 to 2011, and 23.5 percent among projects built from 1998 to 2001.

Low wind turbine pricing continues to push down installed project costs. Wind turbine equipment prices have fallen to $750-$950/kilowatt (kW), and these declines are pushing down project-level costs. The average installed cost of wind projects in 2017 was $1,610/kW, down $795/kW from the peak in 2009 and 2010.
Wind energy prices remain low. Lower installed project costs, along with improvements in capacity factors, are enabling aggressive wind power pricing. After topping out at 7 cents per kWh in 2009, the average levelized long-term price from wind power sales agreements has dropped to around 2 cents per kWh – though this nationwide average is dominated by projects that hail from the lowest-priced region, in the central United States. Recently signed wind energy contracts compare favorably to projections of the fuel costs of gas-fired generation. These low prices have spurred demand for wind energy from both traditional electric utilities and nonutility purchasers, such as corporations, universities, and municipalities.

The domestic supply chain for wind equipment is diverse. Wind sector employment reached a new high of 105,500 full-time workers at the end of 2017. For wind projects recently installed in the United States, domestically manufactured content is highest for nacelle assembly (more than 90 percent), towers (70 to 90 percent), and blades and hubs (50 to 70 percent). It is much lower (less than 20 percent) for most components internal to the turbine. Although there have been a number of manufacturing plant closures over the last decade, each of the three largest turbine suppliers serving the U.S. market – Vestas, General Electric Co., and Siemens Gamesa – has one or more domestic manufacturing facilities in operation.

The Department of Energy’s release on this study is available at energy.gov/windreport.

Berkeley Lab www.lbl.gov
Press Release dated August 23, 2018

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Rooftop Solar Arrays on Five Fire Stations Expected to Reduce Electric Costs 30% for Less Than $1,500

The Dubuque City Council recently approved agreements with Eagle Point Solar of Dubuque for the installation of rooftop solar arrays on five of the City’s six fire stations. The project is expected to reduce electricity costs at the stations by more than 30 percent.

The contract award follows a request for proposal process which generated responses from five firms. The City Council unanimously approved a power purchase agreement and a collateral assignment agreement with Eagle Point Solar for the installation of rooftop solar arrays....

Once installed, the arrays are expected to permanently reduce the City’s cost of each kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity utilized in the five fire stations by more than 30 percent. Specifically, the terms of the contract include a $0.085/kWh initial rate with a three percent inflation rate. This compares with the current aggregate Alliant Energy rate for the fire facilities of $0.116/kWh. The only upfront funding required for this project from the City is for equipment upgrades to allow internet connectivity for the solar arrays, not to exceed $1,500.The percentage of electricity use offset and carbon dioxide offset at each station varies, due to available roof space and usage at that site:

  • Headquarters 66.15 kW Electric Offset 37% CO2 Offset 1,651 tons
  • Station 2 35.28 kW Electric Offset 96% CO2 Offset 887 tons
  • Station 3 27.72 kW Electric Offset 55% CO2 Offset 697 tons
  • Station 4 15.75 kW Electric Offset 26% CO2 Offset 377 tons
  • Station 5 5.04 kW Electric Offset 28% CO2 Offset 128 tons
  • Total System Size 150.8 kW Carbon Offset 3,740 tons
According to Eagle Point Solar, the combination of the five solar arrays, over their lifetime, will offset the equivalent of: planting 87,141 trees, the reduction of 7.48 million automobile miles driven (or 381,480 gallons of gasoline), recycling 11,818 tons of waste rather than landfilling it, displacing carbon dioxide emissions from the annual electricity use of 425 homes, or 1,822 tons of coal burned.

Thursday, November 3, 2016

New Report Finds More Wind Energy Would Provide Benefits for Iowa Business, Homeowners - Adding 10,000 MW of Wind Could Save Ratepayers $12.6 Billion Over 25 Years

A new report detailing the benefits of wind energy for Iowa consumers, both corporate and residential, was released today at event with the Greater Des Moines Partnership. The report models the electricity rate impacts of doubling the currently operating and planned wind power production in the state, and was produced by the A Renewable America campaign in collaboration with the American Wind Energy Association.

“Wind energy investments in Iowa have been a significant driver in attracting advanced manufacturing companies and data centers to our state,” said Jay Byers, CEO of the Greater Des Moines Partnership. “Iowa’s expanding wind energy portfolio and commitment to renewable energy is also an important factor in recruiting and retaining top talent.”

As a national leader in wind energy production, the analysis finds even larger consumer savings are possible with further expansion of wind power in the state. Iowa generated 31.3 percent of its electricity from wind last year while maintaining consumer costs below the national average. The report found that adding another 10,000 megawatts of wind beyond what is currently operating and planned would save Iowa consumers about $12.6 billion on net over the next 25 years, with average savings in excess of $500 million. The average industrial consumer would, on net, save about $825,000 on electric bills and the average resident household would save about $3,200 over that period if their electricity needs were met with wind energy.
...
The report also detailed how Iowa consumers benefited from existing wind last year. In 2015, existing Iowa wind provided more than $500 million in gross benefits, or $28 for each MWh. The report also found that wind energy is expected to become an even better investment over time as other fuels are projected to increase in price, according to projections from the U.S. Department of Energy, Wind energy costs are largely fixed for the life of the project and can even decrease due to inflation, while traditional fuels such as natural gas are expected to increase in cost.
“MidAmerican Energy is committed to providing affordable and reliable energy to Iowa consumers,” said Kathryn Kunert, vice president, economic connections and integration. “Wind is an integral part of our energy portfolio that helps us keep energy prices stable and affordable over the long-term. Our rates today are the ninth lowest nationally – about 36 percent below the national average. With our 100 percent renewable energy goal, we look forward to Wind XI, our largest wind project to date that will be built without a rate increase to consumers or assistance from the state.”

In addition to consumer savings, wind energy also creates jobs and provides economic development opportunities to the state. More than 6,000 people are directly employed in the wind industry, and Iowa landowners receive more than $17 million annually in land lease payments in addition to local taxes paid that help build infrastructure like roads, bridges and schools.
...
The report was unveiled during a panel discussion titled “The Business Case for Wind Energy” at The Partnership. Panelists included moderator Director Debi Durham of the Iowa Economic Development Authority; Jay Byers, CEO of the Greater Des Moines Partnership, Kathryn Kunert, Vice President of Economic Connections and Integration at MidAmerican Energy; Michael Goggin, Senior Research Director of the American Wind Energy Association; and John Boorman, Vice President of the Iowa Wind Energy Association.


Wind Energy Foundation http://windenergyfoundation.org
October 17, 2016

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

Reinvigorating Ohio’s Clean Energy Standards Could Save $5B by 2030

Ohio policymakers are at a crossroads. They can create jobs, grow the economy, cut pollution, and save customers money by rebuilding the state’s renewable and energy efficiency policies, or they can continue to let Ohio fall behind in the clean energy economy.

A little background: In 2014, the Ohio Legislature placed a two-year freeze on the state’s energy efficiency and renewable energy standards as a result of political pressure from Ohio’s largest power company, FirstEnergy, among others. The standards required electric utilities to generate 12.5 percent of electricity sales from renewable sources, as well as reduce energy consumption 22 percent by 2025 through efficiency programs. Since the freeze, Ohio has lost millions of dollars in energy investment and jobs, and lags behind nearly every other state in percentage of renewable energy generated.

Now that the two years are almost up, it’s time for Ohio to decide how to move forward – if at all – on its clean energy standards. Fortunately, according to a new report from Environmental Defense Fund and The Nature Conservancy, there are at least three achievable routes to reinstate the renewable and efficiency standards – each of which would provide substantial economic and health benefits to the state at a value of $3 to $5 billion by 2030.
...
To evaluate the most financially beneficial mix of clean energy resources, the report, Grounds for Optimism: Options for Empowering Ohio’s Energy Market, produced three forecasts of the state’s electricity market. The scenarios include an Accelerated Efficiency case, an Intermediate Pathway that provides a balanced mix of renewables and efficiency, and an Expanded Renewables case. These scenarios are compared against a baseline that models an extended freeze of Ohio’s renewable and energy-efficiency standards.

All three scenarios are based on clear trends and achievable targets within the state’s growing clean energy industry. Furthermore, each would enable Ohio to meet the goals of the Clean Power Plan, the nation’s first-ever limit on carbon pollution from power plants.

The forecasts show the renewable energy and energy efficiency industries in Ohio are expected to:
  • Create between 82,300 and 136,000 new jobs in Ohio, with the wind industry serving as one of the largest contributors.
  • Enhance Ohio’s GDP by $6.7 billion to $10.7 billion by 2030,
  • Provide between $28.8 million and $50.9 million in savings for Ohio electricity customers by 2030, and
  • Provide between $3 and $5 billion in net benefits by 2030.
Moreover, how we generate electricity significantly impacts public health. Currently, “Ohio’s coal-heavy generating fleet creates billions in public health costs that are borne by citizens,” according to the report. By increasing renewable energy and efficiency, Ohioans would avoid asthma attacks, heart attacks, pulmonary issues, and other illnesses that would otherwise occur under the baseline. And public health benefits grow over time: The value would exceed $1 billion every year from 2030 onward in all three scenarios.
...
Ohio Governor John Kasich recently attended The Texas Tribune festival, where he was asked about his stance on the Buckeye State’s clean energy standards. Although he feels the original policies were overly ambitious, he was very clear on his message to the Ohio legislature, stating, “If you try to kill the standards […], I’ll veto the bill and we’ll go to the higher standards. I’m committed to it.”

In other words, Governor Kasich is determined to see Ohio thaw the freeze and begin to rebuild its clean energy prowess.

If the legislature is wondering how to go about doing so, this new report from The Nature Conservancy and Environmental Defense Fund can serve as a roadmap to getting the Buckeye State back on track. It clearly lays out three paths for creating jobs and growing the state’s economy, while lowering electricity bills and healthcare costs for Ohioans in the long run. The analysis offers flexibility and an array of options, all of which are far superior to letting the freeze stand, or replacing the standards with a toothless goal. The clean energy choices are there – take your pick, Ohio.

Download the full report here and the factsheet here.

http://tinyurl.com/zrrxlzc
Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) www.EDF.org
October 24, 2016

Friday, February 26, 2016

The Hidden Battery - Opportunities in Electric Water Heating

The nation’s 50 million residential electric water heaters collectively represent a significant – and vastly underutilized – energy storage resource capable of leveraging substantial environmental and cost benefits according to new research commissioned by the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA), the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), the Peak Load Management Alliance (PLMA) and Great River Energy (GRE).

This finding from the global economic consulting firm The Brattle Group was announced today (Feb. 10, 2016) at the launch of an initiative designed to promote growth in a novel, community-based approach to energy storage, dubbed “community storage.” By aggregating distributed energy technologies and home appliances, electric cooperatives are developing community storage to increase energy efficiency, better integrate renewable energy resources onto the grid, and reduce customers’ monthly electric bill.
One such community storage program managed by Minnesota-based generation and transmission cooperative Great River Energy has been able to store a gigawatt of energy each night by controlling the electric resistance water heaters of 65,000 end-use members.

“At Great River Energy, we believe there’s a battery hidden in basements all across our service territory,” said Gary Connett, director of member services at Great River Energy. “When the wind is blowing or the sun is shining, large capacity water heaters can be enabled to make immediate use of that energy to heat water to high temperatures. The water heaters can be shut down when renewables are scarce and wholesale costs are high.”

Even in regions heavily reliant on coal and natural gas to generate electricity, the Brattle research shows that consumers have options for saving money on their electric bills and reducing carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions associated with their water heating. Consumers can reduce CO2 emissions by up to 30 percent using their water heater as a thermal battery. Consumers can reduce their CO2 emissions by more than 50 percent using heat pump water heaters.

These same consumers will be enabling integration of clean, renewable resources. Further, the emission reductions of community storage will compound as more consumers participate and the electricity sector transitions to cleaner fuels and generation technologies.

“Co-ops have been controlling large water heaters for decades in order to reduce demand at peak times, which also reduces members’ electric bills. A community storage program using advanced water heaters allows us to do even more: we can store energy, we can optimize the power grid by shaping demand and we can integrate more renewable resources,” said Keith Dennis, NRECA’s senior principal for end-use solutions and standards.

“Smart, grid-connected electric water heaters represent a promising possibility for a more efficient, more economic, and ultimately lower-emissions electricity system,” said Robin Roy, director of building energy efficiency and clean energy strategy at the NRDC. “Given that water heating represents more than 15 percent of household energy use, this is a great opportunity to cut energy waste and also the emissions from electricity generation.”...

[Using data from the PJM and Midcontinent ISO markets, and relying on detailed simulations of water heater operations, the authors evaluate several different approaches for controlling the load of the water heaters. They find that the net benefits of these approaches could reach around $200 per participant per year under certain market conditions. This would effectively pay for the entire cost of the water heater and associated control equipment (including installation) in five years.

Electric water heaters are essentially pre-installed thermal batteries that are sitting idle in more than 50 million homes across the U.S....Electric water heaters account for 9% of all electricity consumed by households nationally. This represents the third single largest source of residential electricity consumption, behind only space cooling (13%) and lighting (11%). More than 40 percent of U.S. households have electric water heating.

Figure ES-1 shows the estimated incremental annualized net benefits of each of the water heating strategies analyzed in this study, based on market prices observed in PJM in 2014.5 These net benefits are incremental relative to maintaining an uncontrolled 50-gal ERWH (the baseline assumption).


 
The environmental impacts of ERWHs depend heavily on the water heating control strategy being  considered and the composition of the generation supply mix of the power system. Generally, HPWHs provide the most consistent environmental benefit on a per-water heater basis through overall reductions in energy consumption, reducing CO2 emissions by approximately 50% relative to an uncontrolled ERWH in our analysis.

 

The system peak load reductions provided by the Peak Shave strategy make it particularly economic in markets where there is a need for new generating capacity. Net benefits per water heater in the PJM 2014 and MISO 2028 scenarios are $13 and $29 per customer per year, respectively. At very low capacity prices such as those in the MISO 2014 scenario, however, the avoided costs do not overcome the incremental cost of the equipment needed to control the water heater, with a net benefit of -$15 per customer per year....